Green Voices is an interview series produced by A greener life, a greener world. In this first episode, we speak to Ketan Joshi, a clean energy expert and commentator about Planet of the Humans and the clean energy industry.
By Anders Lorenzen
Ketan Joshi is a clean energy expert and communicator with a background in the clean energy industry.
He was one of the first to thoroughly debunk the facts in the film ‘Planet of the Humans’, Jeff Gibbs and Michael Moore’s controversial documentary which labels renewables as fraudulent and his opinions were shared widely on social media by climate change, scientists and energy experts alike.
I caught up with Ketan on Zoom, to talk further about his views on the documentary, you can watch the full conversation here.
Joshi was keen to make the point he felt it was a great shame that the filmmakers set out to create an essentially deceptive film when they had a chance to do something important for the environment.
He explained that although he already had low expectations of the film before he watched it he was surprised by just how bad it was and how incorrect the facts were. He acknowledged that there was a valid point around how the renewable energy industry could do a better job of maintaining sites at the end of life shelf for solar and wind farms.
He shared his view that the filmmakers had rushed to put the film together without adequate fact-checking to launch a product during the COVID-19 lockdown period, to take advantage of, essentially, captive audience. This was further evidenced, he said, by interviews with them in which they had called for a ‘youth climate movement’ to rise up to combat climate change, which of course is something that has been taking place for several years now, suggesting that they were very out of touch with current affairs.
Our conversation touches on the hypocrisy of several of the narratives propagated by Gibbs, including him calling for a reduction in consumption, driving and travelling, whilst its plain to see that in the film he himself is driving around in a large gas-guzzling car.
Joshi also pointed out that despite the film showcasing outdated renewables technology which was less efficient than current versions of the same technology, the data the filmmakers used and subsequent verdict on the industry was still bad and incorrect
Of course, our conversation also included the status quo of the clean energy transition and what the issues and challenges are there.
You can find the full conversation below, connect with Joshi on Twitter and find the writings he refers to here and here.
Thanks for the interview. Added here: http://getenergysmartnow.com/2020/04/25/moores-boorish-planet-of-the-humans-an-annotated-collection/
LikeLiked by 1 person
That documentary was so dreadful. I watched it just after it came out on Earth Day. I’ve worked in the alternative energy field for decades and can say with confidence that 95% of the film is inaccurate and distorted. Some of their “facts” are over a decade out of date and they just didn’t bother to update viewers on the vast improvements that have been made since then. A lazy and intentionally deceptive documentary.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“He shared his view that the filmmakers had rushed to put the film together without adequate fact-checking to launch a product during the COVID-19 lockdown period, to take advantage of, essentially, captive audience.” Actually, Mr. Joshi fairly attributes this to Prof. Leah Stokes, saving himself from being corrected, for the documentary premiered in July 2019 at the Traverse City Film Festival. Furthermore, it was fact-checked and all petty claims of outdated data are refuted at the film’s website, PlanetoftheHumans.com.
“This was further evidenced… [because Gibbs & Moore] called for a ‘youth climate movement’ to rise up to combat climate change… suggesting that they were very out of touch with current affairs.”
But clearly the filmmakers aren’t satisfied with the *current* ‘youth climate movement’ which has been misled and so is calling for widespread deployment and use of technologies to continue generating electrical power to sustain the global holocaust of Civilization, albeit CO2-free. Insofar as groups like Sunrise Movement and the Center for Biological Diversity (and arguably even Extinction Rebellion) are pushing for the farce Green New Deal – which is essentially govt. subsidy to renewable energy firms and the perpetuation of growing The Economy – the present push of youths is useless for saving wild Nature, and good only for keeping us dependent upon technology, and those who control it (or serve it). Of course, for those atop the power hierarchy of techno-industrial mass-society, that is certainly preferable to having all of the world revert to small-scale hunter-gatherer social groups.
View at Medium.com
LikeLiked by 1 person